Editorial Review

Nurturing Decent Human Beings: The Case for Moral Education in Our Schools, by Michael Nill | Book Review

Maria Ashford September 4, 2025

Book Review

There are some books that you would never see yourself reading, but end up picking up for whatever reason and really enjoying them anyway. Michael Nill’s Nurturing Decent Human Beings: The Case for Moral Education in Our Schools is one of those types of books. It’s a non-fiction book that insists—firmly but gently—that we pause, look up from our test scores and timetables, and ask the oldest and most important of questions: what kind of people do we hope our children will become?

Nill, a seasoned educator, former headmaster and scholar with a background in Greek and Latin, begins his case in the company of Achilles and Sophocles. From those ancient figures he draws a clear thread to the modern classroom, where the dramas of morality play out daily in ways both obvious and subtle. A torn campaign poster before a school assembly, a speech to a room of graduates, the handling of a bullying incident in the corridor—these, he reminds us, are as morally instructive as any textbook. Nill thankfully provides plentiful examples throughout the book, making it more easy to read for the average reader.

The heart of Nill’s argument is fairly simple: schools cannot escape the work of moral education, because every lesson taught, every policy adopted, and every hallway interaction already conveys values. The real choice is whether to do this by accident or with thought and purpose. In his view, a school that integrates moral education into its fabric is not imposing doctrine but cultivating decency, such as civility, compassion, honesty, responsibility, those timeless virtues that enable young people to flourish both as individuals and as members of a community. Personally, as someone who studied ethics in college, I completely agree with Nill that this type of thing should be taught in schools and not restricted to college students. In fact, in many ways it seems like only teaching ethics to people who choose to study it is against the point.

What gives the book its particular enjoyability is Nill’s own voice: part philosopher, part headmaster, always a storyteller. His anecdotes ring true to anyone who has ever taught, the joy of sparking curiosity in a young mind, the sting of injustice when students are silenced or mocked, the pride of watching graduates step forward as young adults with values intact. He writes with the authority of someone who has lived these questions in real schools, not only in the realm of abstract theory, and keeps his argument relatively succinct at 158 pages.

Nor does Nill shy away from the challenges. He acknowledges our cultural tendency to prize “résumé virtues” (wealth, status, achievement) over “eulogy virtues” (kindness, humility, integrity), and he recognises how political divisiveness and suspicion often make schools wary of moral discussions. Yet his response is a strident insistence that decency can be reclaimed if educators, parents, and policymakers are willing to see moral formation as central to the mission of schooling.

This is not the type of book we oft read on this site. At times, the book reads like an academic treatise, and that’s because it sort of is (along with an extensive bibliography). One moment Nill is pointing out how fairness in grading carries implicit moral lessons; the next he is guiding us through the thorny thickets of cultural relativism and political suspicion. Still, it’s written in a (mostly) accessible writing style that means anyone can pick it up, not just the college-educated. Nill’s compass never wavers: young people deserve to be educated not just for jobs but for life—for meaningful lives, responsible citizenship, and the capacity to make the world better.

This is not to say every reader will agree with him. In fact, in these turbulent political waters in some ways Nill’s argument is quite provocative. Some may wish for more concrete “how-to” instructions for teachers under pressure, while others may find his optimism ambitious in an age of shrinking budgets and crowded curricula. But Nill anticipates such objections, and his answer is to remind us that moral education need not be a separate subject squeezed into an already overburdened schedule. It is, rather, the air schools already breathe; the task is to breathe it with intention.

In the end, what makes Nurturing Decent Human Beings so persuasive is its hopefulness. It is a book that aspires, against cynicism, that schools can be better, where students learn not only how to calculate or analyse but how to treat one another with respect. Like all the best teachers, it doesn’t scold or sermonise; rather, it invites us to imagine better, to do better, and to believe that goodness can be taught, not as dogma, but as lived example. A thoughtful, wise, book that deserves a place in every educator’s or pedagogical academic’s library.

You can get your copy of Nurturing Decent Human Beings: The Case for Moral Education in Our Schools here!

Overall Rating
Keep Reading

More Books to Explore