Editorial Review

Charlotte’s Ghosts: The Mystery of the Vanishing Boy, by L. P. Simone—Book Review

Maria Ashford February 8, 2025

Book Review

“Charlotte’s Ghost” breathes fresh life into the middle-grade ghost story by grounding its supernatural elements in real history. L.P. Simone’s novel follows thirteen-year-old Charlotte Cross, who moves to Manassas, Virginia after her father’s death in Afghanistan. During runs on the historic battlefield near her new home, she encounters Jeremy Turner, a Civil War-era boy who vanished from his family over 170 years ago.

This story stands out through its intelligent use of the supernatural as a lens for exploring childhood grief. Although it will be enjoyable for most people, young readers grappling with loss will find profound resonance in Charlotte’s journey. Her father’s absence permeates her daily life in relatable details: the once-beloved running trails she now avoids, the flinch when classmates casually mention their dads, the mounting pressure to maintain her academic excellence without his guidance. When Charlotte encounters Jeremy’s ghost and his unresolved past, the supernatural elements flow organically from the story’s emotional core, as she discovers in his spectral presence a mirror of her own yearning for closure.

The historical sections of Jeremy’s flashback chapters shine in their attention to detail. Through Jeremy’s eyes, we experience the civil war’s impact on ordinary families caught between Union and Confederate forces. His chapters capture both the daily realities of farm life and the mounting tensions that eventually drive him to enlist under a false name, leaving his Quaker mother behind. These sections avoid both romanticism and excessive grittiness that would be too much for kids, instead showing how war tears at family bonds in ways that resonate across centuries.

The contemporary storyline balances Charlotte’s ghost-hunting with convincing middle school drama. Her tentative friendship with Josh Gerber and their unlikely alliance with class troublemaker Eric Finson feels genuine, complete with awkward moments and gradually earned trust. The adults in Charlotte’s life – particularly her mother and Coach Elsberry – struggle with their own issues while trying to support her, making them feel fully realized characters rather than mere background figures.

The parallel narratives of the book build effectively toward their intersection at the climax, as Charlotte realizes that helping Jeremy make peace with his mother might help her process her own loss. The climactic race sequence masterfully brings together the physical and emotional threads of Charlotte’s journey, showing how she has grown stronger by facing both supernatural and very human challenges.

The novel’s greatest strength may be its reliability to children without being patronising or giving easy answers about grief and loss. While Jeremy’s ghost finds resolution, Charlotte’s pain doesn’t magically disappear. Instead, she learns to carry her father’s memory forward in a way that honors rather than haunts her. This emotional authenticity elevates what could have been a simple ghost story into something more meaningful.

Minor pacing issues in the historical sections and some predictable middle school dynamics don’t significantly detract from the novel’s impact. Simone has crafted a story that will resonate with young readers navigating their own experiences of loss and change, while offering enough supernatural intrigue and historical detail to keep them engaged throughout.

“Charlotte’s Ghost” is recommended for readers 11-14, particularly those who appreciate ghost stories or stories that blend history with contemporary themes. L. P. Simone has written a thoughtful exploration of how the past echoes into the present, and how we learn to live with the spaces left by those we’ve lost.

You can buy “Charlotte’s Ghost” by L. P. Simone here!

Overall Rating
Keep Reading

More Books to Explore